Poll: What to do with Jonathan Villar?

Jonathan Villar is playing like a star. I don’t necessarily know if he is a star, but he’s definitely playing like one. A few weeks ago I wrote about how his stardom came from essentially nowhere, and frankly I’m surprised his performance hasn’t tailed off yet.

We’re less than a month away from the All-Star break, and Villar is still riding a .390 on-base percentage thanks in large part to an insane .401 BABIP. He’s MLB’s seventh-best shortstop according to WAR, has created 23% more runs than league average and has stolen more bases than anyone. Being one of the best players on a rebuilding Brewers team, which Villar is, isn’t of much significance, but he’s been more than that. He’s transformed into one of the best leadoff hitters in the game, even with Orlando Arcia‘s shadow cast over him since he arrived in Milwaukee.

Because he’s been so valuable to the Brewers, his future is even more questionable than it once was. It’s obvious that teams will be interested in him as the trade deadline approaches. Yet general manager David Stearns has said that there’s little motivation to trade him, and that makes sense. Villar is a young, controllable talent, and as Stearns stated, that’s the exact type of player the Brewers want right now. Still, trading him could net a sizable return for the same reasons.

If the Brewers decide to hold on to their diamond in the rough, moving him to second base seems likely. Villar’s days at shortstop are numbered and that’s not just because Arcia is almost ready to make his major-league debut. He’s a good defender, yes. That’s evident by his 3 Defensive Runs Saved this season (even though UZR has a drastically different opinion of his fielding abilities), but he’d probably provide more value at second. It’s a much easier position to field and doesn’t require many long throws, something Villar has had a problem with at times this year.

That, though, leaves Scooter Gennett on the outside looking in, and that, honestly, is the way it should be. To be frank, he’s just not a good player, especially in relation to Villar. He lacks OBP skills and his wRC+ has fallen in every season of his career. I wouldn’t be surprised to see Gennett traded if the Brewers decide to retain Villar. It would make sense.

Another option for Villar is to take over third base duties when Aaron Hill inevitably leaves, whether that be in free agency this winter or in a trade this season. There’s a low likelihood to that though, in my opinion. He’s shown some surprising power so far, but teams usually want their hot corner guys to be big boppers, and Villar definitely doesn’t fit that label. Stearns may have his own ideas for the position, though.

This dilemma is a good one to have if you’re Milwaukee, and it shows why teams take fliers on players like Villar. You never know what you have until you give them a shot.


7 thoughts on “Poll: What to do with Jonathan Villar?

  1. Ken Frank

    Why waste Villar’s arm at second? Also, Gennett has shown improved OBP skills as a he gains experience (only 2 years service time). I’ll take Villar at third with 12-15 bombs and an amazing OBP with a ton of stolen bases. That compared to a .250 guy with very little steals, lower OBP and 25 bombs. All of this if Gennett continues to be the player we’ve since since his recall last year (average fielding % and above average range included). Who am I though??? Just guessing like everyone else…. Enjoy the season!


  2. Anonymous

    At this point Villar’s downside offensively is probably something like his 2015 line, which isn’t terrible (basically what they traded for when they gave up Cy Sneed), while his upside is a ton better… unless other teams are willing to actually pay up in a meaningful way for some of that unproven upside (doubtful without a longer track record of success), there’s really no reason to trade him for at least another year. By then, the Brewers will have a better idea about how their rebuild is coming along and what they have in Villar.


  3. Anonymous

    Scooter drives me crazy. I don’t know what it is. Every time I hear his name I want to throw my Miller Lite through the TV. HIs numbers don’t match my level of frustration, but I would love nothing more than to see him in another uniform.
    “Aaandd that one is juuust out of the reach of Scooter Gennett !!” Ugh


  4. Anonymous

    I know what you mean about Scooter… I think it is because I was a huge Week’s fan. I guess looking back Rickie had a few great years and not much more than that. Probably not fair for me to hold such a grudge against the scooter. I should probably be a fan given I’m an undersized white guy too.



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s